Mascara Supreme 2021 Formulas

(21 reviews) Write a Review
Item Code:
Gift wrapping:
Options available
Henna Supreme Sensitive Mascara
Chestnut Supreme Sensitive Eye
Spice Supreme Waterproof
+ Add another color

Mascara Supreme

JFR has created two very special formulas to address two very special redhead needs. A waterproof formula, and a special sensitive eye formula in two shades for very sensitive eyes. 

Supreme Waterproof - Available in Spice Supreme. Our waterproof formula is removable with soap and water or with our Gentle Rescue Makeup remover. Has been worn by US Women's Swim Team.  

Supreme Sensitive Eye - Available in Chestnut Supreme and Henna Supreme. Great for contact lens wearers and those with eye sensitivities. Even those previously unable to wear mascara love our sensitive eye formula.


21 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    62 yo

    Posted by SusanK on Feb 1st 2021

    I'm really active and live in FL. Finding a good waterproof mascara that is sweatproof is at the top of my list. What I got was an easy to apply mascara in the perfect color. I thought I'd give the JFR brand a try and now I won't use anything else.

  • 4

    Posted by on Dec 21st 2020

    Like the waterproof but wish it came in a lighter colour.

  • 5
    Lovely Mascara

    Posted by Eronelle on Oct 2nd 2020

    I got the Supreme Sensitive Mascara in the color henna. I like it a lot and it doesn't irritate my eyes at all. The color is very good for me and it is easy to apply. It doesn't clump or smear so I don’t have to clean my skin with a Q-tip afterwards like most mascaras. It gives a very soft natural look to the lashes.

  • 5
    The mascara I have been waiting for!

    Posted by Angela Lutes on Sep 30th 2020

    The mascara supreme in brown is everything I look for in a mascara. I have short, white, and thin eyelashes. A recent illness has also made them sparse and dry. The mascara supreme made my lashes soft and full, not spiky as other brands do. The brown color is natural and long-lasting. Best of all, I wore the mascara for hours and my eyes did not burn at all. I will definitely buy again.

  • 5
    Love the color and the sensitivity of the product. Most mascaras make me itch , not this one!

    Posted by on Sep 13th 2020

    Being a red head has been difficult to find gentle colors of make up , love the browns ! Thank you!

  • 5
    Mascara Supreme

    Posted by Vonda Turner on Sep 4th 2020

    I have been using Just For Redheads products for many many years. The mascara keeps getting better and better.

  • 5
    Supreme mascara

    Posted by Lori on Sep 3rd 2020

    Truly made for sensitive eyes. This is the only mascara that has not irritated my eyes or made my eyes water. Color is natural, much better looking than black.

  • 5
    This is the best mascara! I have had many products being a redhead and this one by far is the best. It’s stays on all day, doesn’t smudge under the eye, the color is a true redhead eyelash I even stared to order it for my blond mother, who is no

    Posted by Sheryl Nummy on Aug 14th 2020

    Only complaint is sometimes it gets clumpy and I have to get a new one sooner than I would prefer

  • 5
    Supreme 2020 Mascara

    Posted by Kathlyn Buss on Feb 28th 2020

    Spice Supreme is the perfect color for me. Stays on and doesn't flake.